Monday, November 30, 2009
Distance in Lahari's Interpreter of Maladies
In “A Temporary Matter,” the man and wife lost their child and since then were unable to see each other without remembering their loss. The husband attempts to rekindle the passion in their relationship by turning out all the lights and revealing all of their secrets. The wife tells the husband near the end of the story that she had found an apartment and was going to move out. The husband reveals that he had held the deceased infant and knew the sex.
In “Interpreter of Maladies,” the tour guide and driver looks at this couple he has in his car that seems incompatible. The couple has three children, two boys and a girl. The mother appears to be detached from them. He dreams of having a secret affair with the wife but finds out when the child is surrounded by monkeys and the parents join together to save him that their relationship may seem strange but it works for them.
The story “This Blessed House,” is about a couple moving in to a new home. The wife discovers many “Christian paraphernalia” in the house. The wife loves them and wants to display them all over the house. However they are Christians and the husband is concerned about what the neighbors and people from his job will think. He wants to destroy it all but for some reason he doesn’t. his wife delights in finding these things all over the house.
“The Treatment of Bibi Haladar” speaks of a female that has an extreme case of epilepsy. The doctor diagnoses sexual interaction as a cure for illness. The epilepsy interferes with her everyday life and because she could never function very long her parents failed to show her the rituals that all women were supposed to be able to follow by as a wife. When people realized that she was incapable of doing these things no one wanted to marry her. When her brother’s wife becomes pregnant they move Bibi to another part of the house which shuts her off from everybody because they fear that her illness will bring harm to the child. The child is born healthy but falls ill one day after Bibi is moved back down to the main part of the house. Bibi is sent back to her area above the house and when the family moves away she refuses to come down. They discover that she was pregnant. Bibi was distanced from the family as well as from others because of her disease.
In Mr. Pirzada Came to Dine, Mr. Pirazada visits a family’s home before and during Halloween. He is distanced from his family who are in a war zone. He becomes attached to the family’s little girl because she is much like his daughter’s.
In “The Third and Final continent,” the elderly lady who allows the young man to live n her home is distanced from the world. In that everything has changed so since when she was young because she is 103 years old and has dementia.
In the story “Mrs. Sen’s,” Mrs. Sen is distanced from her sister, her birth home, and her husband who works a lot. She has to learn how to drive so that she can get around. She babysits a young boy and they form a strong bond. He is distanced from his mother.
The story “Sexy” has two main characters the female who is going with the married man and a child that seems whose father is cheating on his mother. There should be a distance between the boy’s mother and father in the story and the man who is having an affair and his wife; but there isn’t. The wife is “beautiful”. Yet the females that the men are cheating with are “sexy”. Therefore its more about sexual freedom or desire rather than filling some void that the marriage isn’t fulfilling anymore.
The story “The Real Duran” focuses on good luck charms and witch craft. The woman is distant from her home but this isn’t the primary focus, even though she is shunned when they find out that she can’t ward off anything.
Monday, November 23, 2009
Trethewey's Mark
Men as Boys in Bastard Out of Carolina
Thursday, November 19, 2009
Trethewey's Language
I really only enjoyed a few poems from the first section of the book. My favorite poem overall is "After Your Death." This was the only poem that seems to have real emotion behind it, and the language flows really well and is actually very pretty. Phrases like "I twisted a ripe fig loose from its stem" and "I'm too late, again, another space emptied by loss" exemplify simplicity in language but are still poignant and meaningful. Trethewey proves that she does know how to write beautiful words (she did win the Pulitzer, after all) and create true emotion through those words.
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
High-school Poetry
Tretheway's style of writing is simple and easy to understand. I find it easy to read, which makes it easy to relate to. The poetry has a flow that is easy to read that adds to it's function. This collection would be a wonderful collection to read in a high-school poetry section. The subject matter isn't too complex, the text isn't too lengthy, it's based on topics that are relevant to today's youth, and teens of all ages could relate to it in their search for identity I thoroughly enjoyed reading Tretheway's Native Guard, it was both educational and entertaining.
We are in Control of how we Absorb History
Trethewey talks about her own personal history in her poems. The first section of the book deals almost entirely with the death of her mother and how that affected her throughout her life. Poems like "What is Evidence" and "Photograph: Ice Storm, 1971" Trethewey describes how her mother was physically abused and how it affected her. In the poem, "What is Evidence" Trethewey further explores the abuse her mother suffered. This is most clear in the lines "Only the landscape of her body - splintered clavicle, pierced temporal - her thin bones settling a bit each day, the way all things do." She is referring to her mother's buried body, showing all of the scars of abuse from when she was alive. In this way her mother is just like the members of the Native Guard buried on Ship Island. This book teaches that we are in control of how we absorb history, and that we are not a result of past events but the result of the way we interpret those events.
Analyzing Tretheway’s Native Guard Without Biographical Interpretations
Can we really look at text without trying to analyze how much of it came from the writer’s life? Well let’s try. During the poetry festival, Natasha Tretheway stated that she really disliked it when people tried to figure out how much of her writing came from experiences that occurred throughout her life. No one likes anyone probing into the sad parts or darker parts of their lives; however those parts of our lives drive our emotions in our writing and allows us to be viewed as human. Our goal when we write is to make an experience seem real. Thus, if we achieve that people are going to assume that we are writing about an actual occurrence. Therefore, let’s remove these thoughts from our mind for a moment and just analyze Tretheway’s poetry without biographical knowledge and interpretation of her life. Does this take away or add anything to the poem?
For the sake of brevity, i will only analyze the poems "Myth." Tretheway writes all of the poems of this book in first person. in the poem myth she used the word "Erebus." Erebus is a reference from Greek mythology which refers to a deity and a place. The diety was the son of Kaos and darkness and the brother of Nyx (night).the place is the underworld. Tretheway uses Erebus as an underworld which is used as metaphor for her memories and dreams.
Throughout the poem, there is a lot of repetition of phrases. We see this in the lines "I was asleep while you were dying, it was as if you slipped through some rift, a hollow, i make between my slumber and my waking, sleep heavy turning." If you look closely, you will notice that the poem has sort of a ballad rhythm. Its almost like a pendulum swinging back and forth. The first repeated phrase "I was asleep while you were dying" has a change in tone and meaning as it is repeated on the last line. First, it appears that the author is stating what happened, and in the last line, the phrase seems to saying that he/she missed the last moment that the person was alive. The phrase "sleep heavy turning" is repeated. However at one point, its not the persona who is sleep but the deceased. The narrator was in a deep sleep while the person was dying however in the next mention of the phrase it describes the deceased in eternal sleep. the deep sleep that the narrator speaks of is him or her not seeing the small hints given that signified that the deceased was going to die. The entire poem switches around phrases which adds to the pendulum effect. The pendulum effect demonstrates how the person went away every time the narrator awoke.
The rhyme in this poem is abcabc, the middle two stanzas end the lines with the words "turning", "follow", and "forsaking". The last stanzas imitate the same rhyme scheme as the first two stanzas. The stanzas are written in tercets.
To answer the question: If you remove the biographical interpretations away from the poem does the poem maintain the same effect? The answer is yes. When people ask questions about the author's life, sometimes its because they are looking for someone that has been through the same thing as themselves, or they are simply curious about the mystery of converting difficult emotions and occurrences into words.
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
The Power of Hearing
In “The Southern Crescent” Trethewey deals with feelings of maturation and memory, of plans failed and set again. The scene is on board a now defunct train line and gives a nostalgic feel that is at once sad and hopeful. Though she is burdened with the memories of past trips “gone wrong”, there is still something that “awaits” her, “the rails humming like anticipation.” The mere reading of this poem is great, but having the author read it allows further insight. I particularly liked hearing her thoughts on seeing her mother’s face in the train window, the author’s own face actually, that nevertheless bears the stamp of her mother.
Trethewey’s reading of “Genus Narcissus” is another example of how a poem can be elucidated in a way the text simply cannot achieve. Trethewey spoke of researching in her work to help themes develop. Sure, the reference to Narcissus seems a fairly apparent parallel to the child’s self interest in the work, and the fact that the poem is titled as it is hints that daffodils are probably termed in Latin as genus narcissus, but I did not know that beforehand. And apparently, neither did Trethewey. I just find it immensely interesting to hear how works progress and come about, and attending these types of readings can afford one such an opportunity. Thank you, Pee Dee Fiction Festival, thank you.
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Refusal to be a Parent
Mishapen Identity
By watching the females in her family, Bone doesn't learn much other than how to tolerate an alcoholic husband. She does learn a lot about life, bad experiences, coping, and hard work from her Aunt Reylene. Most of Bone's advice and learning comes from her Uncle Earl and cousins. She relates more to their strength and the respect through fear that they command. Bone learns to be tough, mean, and hardened by watching her uncles and cousins. She admires the power they hold through the fear they strike in others. Bone learns to deal with pain by inflicting it on others.
With little to no guidance from the women in her family and a group of men from the wrong side of the tracks being the only mentors, it's no wonder Bone gets trapped inside herself in a search for her identity. Bone is not only confused with who she is as a person, she is also surrounded with complete chaos and abuse that leaves her distant, cold, and introverted. When nothing outside your own mind makes sense and you cannot find anyone or anything in which to identify, inside yourself becomes the safest place to be.
Inner Strength
Importance of illegitimacy, seld concept, and class struggle in Bastard Out of Carolina
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Bastard...
As the narrative progresses we forget that Bone is a bastard. We forget about this victimization; it losses it's power within Bone's narrative. The aspect of poverty is also forgotten. Bone and the rest of her family are poor, poor beyond what most will ever be able to comprehend in this age of subsidized housing, medicine and large charity organizations. This oppressive poverty also falls by wayside by the end of the narrative. Only the abuse is left victimize Bone, but she is not dead at the end of the book and we must assume that her narrative will continue beyond the last page. It seems only logical that the abuse she has endured will also fail to define Bone.
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Identity Crisis
Anney expresses her disgust when her aunt makes this statement. But in actuality, she was trying to attain some sense of self worth, in some way or another.
In Bastard out of Carolina , Anney's search of self-fulfillment takes her on a twelve-year journey trying to find social acceptance. The purpose of this journey is to try, in a sense, to shield Bone from future hurt and pain caused by the stigma that is attached to the word "bastarg", but she neglects to see it in the present. Anney's persistance in attempting to remove the word from Bone's birth certificate, in my opinion, is a result of her own selfishness. Although, it generally means a child that it born out of wedlock, the word "bastard" reflects more on the mother than it does the child. Therefore, I feel that Bone being referred to as "bastard" is more of a reflection on Anney than her. During that time, girls/women (who engaged in premarital sex and had a child out of wedlock, especially at an an early age) was considered to be, as my grandmother would say, "fast" or "hot in the pants". The boys/men of course stood blameless. I have heard many stories about girls in those days being "sent up the road" when they became pregnant because of the shame and embarrassment. The poor child usually ends up being referred to as their "brother" or "sister". I think Anney felt as if this was how the world was going to perceive her.
I do not question Anney's love for Bone, but her neglect in trying to teach Bone (which Raylene attempts to do) that other's do not define your identity. In her attempt to "make everything right"(ie. correcting the birth certificate, marrying Glen) Anney has introduced Bone to far more hurt than she could have possibly ever known.
Monday, November 2, 2009
Sexual Abuse
Sunday, November 1, 2009
Sex Addiction
In the story Bastard Out of Carolina, the main character Bone is sexualized at a very young age. She has a great deal of knowledge about sex and masturbates often to masochistic thoughts. After doing some research on sexual addiction, I found that sex addicts are often sexually abused as children. One description of a sexually abused child fit Bone’s situation well. “The child may have grown up in a hostile, chaotic or neglectful home, or the family may have been very normal but the child grows up emotionally starved for love because affection is rarely expressed” (Ewald). Bone starts the book as a happy child, but when her mother marries Glen and begins to abuse her, she isolates herself and expresses anger toward her family. She is desperate for the affection of her mother, however with Glen in the picture, she cannot receive the love she needs and desires. For abused children, sex becomes a comfort to them in many different situations. For Bone, masturbation becomes an escape from her family situation, a method to fall asleep at night, and possibly a way to make her feelings of guilt more tangible. If the story were extended into Bone’s adulthood, could she become a sex addict, an abuser herself, or possibly partake in an abusive relationship with a man? Many critics believe that Bone is a lesbian in the story, but the abuse she suffers at the hands of her step father would obviously make her wary of men. If Dorothy Allison were not practicing an openly gay lifestyle, would the topic of Bone being a lesbian even be explored?